| The History of the Hornsemble in the U.S. The development of the horn ensemble in the United States traces its roots back to the late 1950's. Hornists Max Pottag and Wendell Hoss brought with them from Germany a very rich tradition of horn ensemble performance. The Viennese for example have a rich tradition of an organization for hornists to come together, rehearse, and perform horn ensemble literature since 1860. Today, much of this literature, as well as contemporary Austrian literature, is becoming available through the auspices of the Wiener Waldhorn Verein. Max Pottag was the second hornist of the Chicago Symphony and was also the Horn Professor at Northwestern University. At Northwestern, he formed an ensemble from his studio along with other hornists from the community. At that time, available literature was meager, consisting of arrangements of male quartets, Wagner transcriptions, and orchestral potpourris. His students who subsequently started organizations when they accepted orchestral and university positions inherited the enthusiasm for this ensemble as a venue for musical training. Early performances of this ensemble occurred twice in the late 1950's at the Midwest Band and Orchestra Clinic where Max Pottag conducted horn choir of around 90 members. The members consisted of present students, area professionals, alumni, and other collegiate choirs from across the country. The literature performed included arrangements of symphonic and vocal repertoire, which were expressly written for this event by Pottag. Pottag even encouraged his students to contribute arrangements for this ensemble. The performances at the Midwest Clinic received outstanding acclaim. To the audience, the concerts were a revelation as to the expressive qualities and total range available of such an ensemble. The selections performed were entirely of quartet format. Today that legacy has grown. While there is a wealth of literature for quartet, there are increasing selections being written for 5-8 separate voices. There is even literature available that expands the ensemble to include the euphonium and tuba. For recreation and camaraderie, various areas and regions of the country started forming horn clubs for the sharing of information and recreational performance. Early meetings consisted of reading orchestral passages and performing older European quartet literature. It was not until the 1960's that the educational and musical value of such an ensemble came to fruition. Two such pockets formed in Buffalo, New York and in Los Angeles, California. The Buffalo Horn Club Lowell Shaw, owner of the Hornet's Nest Publishing Company, was a student of Potage's at Northwestern University. In 1956 he won the Second Horn position in the Buffalo Symphony and a year later became Professor at the University of Buffalo. He shared Pottag's devotion of the horn choir as a training tool. He soon organized his collegiate students into a university horn choir. Soon area professionals and high school students began to attend these rehearsals thus establishing a larger organization, the Buffalo Horn Club. The club was primarily a recreational organization sharing information, reading ensemble literature, and giving occasional performances. Shaw loved composition and made arrangements to understand the compositional processes of the Masters. His interest in writing new works in a commercial vein came about through his directing the University of Buffalo Jazz Band. Knowing that he often wrote arrangements for this ensemble, his students requested that he add horn parts to his charts. As training material for learning this commercial style, he started writing a body of works known as Fripperies, which were a light-hearted introduction to the various musical styles found in jazz and commercial music. In the middle of the 1960's he started his publishing company, The Hornist's Nest, to keep up with the demand for requests for his horn ensemble arrangements. To date, over 5,000 copies of his first volume of Fripperies has been sold. The Los Angeles Horn Club In Los Angeles, 36 of the area's finest performers were organized in 1951 to present a horn choir concert similar to those given by Max Pottag in Chicago. This group was organized through the efforts of James Decker and Wendell Hoss and performed for the Music Educators National Conference at the Musician's Union Concert Hall in Hollywood. Max Pottag was the guest conductor. As in Chicago, the audience response was positive. Thus, it gave the group the impetus to meet regularly. Initially, the players had weekly rehearsal and meeting session. The executive officers were Alfred Brain, Wendell Hoss, Arthur Franz, and James Decker. The studio and free-lance hornists that were under contract to the various motion picture, radio, and recording studios were under the guidance of quota laws which prohibited them to perform in other studios with whom they did not have contracts. Thus, the formation of the Los Angeles Horn Club gave these players the opportunity to associate with other gifted hornists and to present regular concerts, which was a valuable aid for the performers to keep in shape. The organization was a boon to film composers as well. Though the film composers were under contract to the studios, they often would agree to write original music for this ensemble to experiment with different sounds and textures. Not only were the hornists able to play first-rate music, but also now these composers were getting their music heard on a more frequent basis. The Horn Club agreed to copy the music and guarantee at least one performance of the submitted work. During the 1950's the first solo recordings of horn music became available. Because of the marketing success of these novel solo recordings, the Artist and Research Producer for Capitol Records, Robert Meyers, contacted the group about the marketability of an album of ensemble music for horn. Through the efforts of Wendell Hoss, arrangements were made with several leading studio and film composers to create special arrangements and original music for the organization. In 1960 the project was completed and was a resounding success. Because of the interest in this project, another recording followed in 1970. Both recordings have since been re-released on compact disc on the EMI label. The chief goal of the Los Angeles Horn Club was the creation of new music for the horn. This was to be accomplished through a series of national contests for composers. Since its inception, the Los Angeles Horn Club has accumulated a large amount of new music for large horn groups (eight or more players). When contracts were ended in 1959 and the union voted quota laws out, many of the hornists became too busy to continue with the weekly meetings. This resulted in groups of amateur and professional hornists meeting to run through some of the vast amount of horn ensemble music written expressly for the Los Angeles Horn Club. Until recently the music, which was on the two recordings, was under the control of the recording company. At present, the control of this has reverted back to the organization. Royalties are still being paid to the composers by the club. Additional holdings are becoming available through composition contests sponsored by the group and unsolicited works arriving by budding composers. Those works which are highly considered are included in the library, entitled "The Wendell Hoss Memorial Library of the Los Angeles Horn Club." This body of work is stored in the horn studio at the University of Southern California. Efforts are underway to make this literature available by James Decker, Professor of Horn at the University of Southern California. The Baltimore Horn Club Leigh Martinet organized a horn club in the Baltimore area. Since the 1970's he has produced a large library of quality transcriptions for multiple horns. While his quartet arrangements are many, his transcriptions of six or more parts are particularly noteworthy for their scoring and colors. The Baltimore Horn Club (BSO) was organized in the mid-1950's. The nucleus of this group was the hornists in the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra and other free-lance players. Leigh Martinet, a public school music teacher and free-lance hornist formed the group. Martinet studied with Charles Lenuty, hornist with the Philadelphia Orchestra, and Jerry Knop of the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra. He enlisted in the Air Force and was a member of the Air Force Band along with Arthur Berv, John Barrows, and Harry Shapiro. At the time the Baltimore Horn Club was formed, publications for horn choirs were meager. The body of available works was those of quartets by Gumpert, Tcherepnine, and arrangements by Pottag. Since Martinet had always enjoyed arranging, he decided to produce new material for the group. The horn club met every other Friday as a venue for recreational playing and socialization. The membership was initially 16 members. Because of his efforts, Leigh was elected president of the organization. Walter Lawson, the second hornist of the BSO, introduced Leigh to Lowell Shaw. It has been a long and profitable relationship. Shaw and Martinet exchanged arrangements and musical ideas. Shaw started publishing some of Martinet's arrangements. It was not long before Martinet started his own publishing house, The Baltimore Horn Club. To date there are 62 items in his catalogue, ranging from 2 to 8 voices. Benefits of Developing a Horn Choir Developing a solid horn section within the musical ensemble is contingent upon a cohesive blend of tone, intonation, and style. The horn's sound by its nature is warm, expressive, and capable of paralleling subtle nuances that is indicative of vocal music. To make this cohesive blend, regular performance of ensemble music is essential. When a regular regimen occurs in homogenous ensemble venues, several benefits will occur. These are 1) a unified tone, 2) improved intonation, 3) articulation variances 4) balance and blend. A unified tonal concept will originate which will help the section gel into one composite tone. While individuals will retain their normal individual conception of sound, this will be somewhat tempered in order to blend in to a homogenous ensemble sound. Greater precision of intonation will occur in tandem with attention to the ensemble blend. Unison and octave scales, lip slur patterns, and interval practice should be a part of the ensembles warm up. In addition to these arbitrary warm-ups, I recommend using Verne Reynolds' Intonation Exercises for Two Horns, which will work on intervalic intonation within the ensemble. This volume works extremely well for ensemble development, as well. The following examples are based from Mr. Reynolds' studies. Such exercises would be unison melodic work to strive for a good homogenous sound, with particular care that individuals cannot be identified. A good rule of thumb is that if you cannot hear anyone else besides yourself, then the volume you are using is too loud. A simple unison blending study is to start on c or g and descend by half-steps, returning to the initial note prior to the next descent. Next, I recommend octave work. The operative point here is that the lower octave must predominate, as if the upper note is an overtone. This will aid intonation and balance. As in any ensemble, it is incumbent of the players to listen "down" through the ensemble. A combination of octaves and unisons is particularly useful. Short scale passages in octaves are ideal for this. Harmonic and melodic intonation is more problematic. To make chords "ring" slight adjustments in tuning are necessary. The most common adjustments are that perfect fifths need to be raised slightly, major thirds are to be lowered, and minor thirds raised. While these adjustments are minute, persistent work will accustom the players to hearing these intervals in tune. Two part exercises can be done effectively for tuning perfect fourths, fifths, thirds, and sixths (ex. 1-3), or can be expanded to three or more voices (ex. 4). From this, short chorales may be beneficial to conclude the warm-up or intonation training procedure. Do not progress to the next chord until the intonation and balance of the chord is correct. Get students to identify the chord root. From this, get unisons and octaves of the root matching. Next, I recommend adding the fifth. When the "phantom third" is noticed, finally add the third of the chord. When entering, all players must be able to clearly discern the root of the chord. This phenomenon of the "phantom" interval is a matter of acoustics, this being the presence of summation and difference tones. Without being overly technical, summation tones occur when the frequency level of both resonant tones combine to produce a phantom note, albeit soft. For example, if one pitch with a frequency of 220 cycles per second (cps) is sounded along with another at 330 cps, a summation tone (a very soft phantom note) of 550 cps may be noticed. Thus, if a perfectly in tune perfect fifth (or twelfth) is performed, a phantom major third will be noticed (ex. 5). Likewise, if a major sixth is perfectly balanced an in tune, a phantom tonic will be noticed (ex. 6). This ghost note represents the phenomenon of a difference tone. The difference between the lower note (330 cps) subtracted from the upper note (550 cps) results in a lower quasi-bass note of 220 cps. Thus, perfectly balanced and in tune ensembles will have added resonance and sound larger because of the additional sympathetic overtones. Conversely, poorly tuned ensembles will sound dull and closed. Thus, when working with chorales it may be beneficial to work with pairs of parts before putting everything together. The Treasury of Scales, published by Belwin is an excellent source for tuning and blend. If you get all four horn books, you will have complete four part chorales representing all major and minor tonalities. Articulation clarity and subtle adjustments will also be essential to address. The horn ensemble, by its nature, is a thick texture and precision in articulation styles will be necessary. To develop a clear and cutting articulation, usually the hornist will need to slow the release of the tongue slightly in order to get a better "bead" to the beginning of the note. Also, specialized articulation techniques such as "backend" tonguing may need to be addressed in fast staccato passages that require punch for clarity and projection. To work on articulation, I would recommend using any of the vast articulation studies out of the first book of Kopprasch's 60 etudes. For advanced players, performing these articulation studies down an octave is especially advantageous as the lower range of the horn tends to be unresponsive. Players will notice that to match articulation and length of upper octave notes, they will need to play these lower octave notes with more punctuation and detachment. Thus, playing such exercises in unison and in octaves would be of particular benefit. Recommended articulation studies are numbers 2, 3, and 4. One may also do these with optional slurs, depending on the conductors whim. Other recommended exercises could be 6, 8, 9, and 10. The first three are particularly useful if also performed without slurs. To get fast crisp staccatos, especially in the lower octave, I recommend that hornists use a tonguing style called "backend tonguing." This is done in very fast passages when a very clean articulation is desired. Initially, I will have the student slur the passage. This not only works with the air flow, but also develops finger rhythm and timing. The flow of the air and the correct timing of the fingers is essential in fast, technical passages. Once the flow and timing have been established, the tongue can be used. With backend tonguing, the release of the tongue is very deliberate, thus making the note pop out of the instrument. If the air is constantly moving, then the slight deliberation of the tongue release causes the air momentarily blocked by the repositioning of the tongue to be more clearly enunciated into the instrument. Thus, by slowing down the release of the tongue, one will play with a more marked articulation. Conversely, if a more legato release is desired, then the release will need to be more swift, as if one tests a hot iron by putting a drop of water on the finger and gently touching the irons surface. The danger will "backend tonguing" is that the tongue must stay in the down position until the last split second when it repositions itself for the next release. Thus, the result is a fat "chunk" of sound (ex. 7). In negotiating this technique, it is best to use a lower tongue position in where the tip of the tongue can barely feel the bottom edge of the top teeth. However, a word of caution is advised, being that if the tongue rises too soon, either a scooping sound "toit" will be noticed, or else there will be more silence rather than tone on the desired pitches (ex. 8). This is why I recommend slurring when working on fast, technical passages. When the air and the fingers are working perfectly in tandem, one then only needs to put the tongue in play and letting the fingers lead the technique. The desired release depends on the style of the passage. The aggressive sound of "backend tonguing" is a special articulation and should be reserved for specific passages. I have heard this technique used many times out of context, so a cautionary word to directors is advisable. To prelude this technique one could use several exercises. The first exercise (ex. 8) could be used as a prelude to scale work. The second exercise (ex. 9) works with several styles of articulation. The first scale sequence should be ultra-legato with a large, sonorous tone. After a quick breath, a normal articulation at the softer dynamic is done. Finally, after a small catch-breath, the soft passage is done with back-end tonguing, creating a very clean articulation. This can be done in ascending or descending half-step increments to facilitate key development. Balance problems may occur with poor ensemble seating. If the ensemble is small set them in the following configurations either in a straight line or a slight arc. At all costs, avoid set-ups with bells facing in a mixture of facing to and away from the audience. With respect to the later two examples of block seating, the ensemble should face the audience. The first chair may still lead visually and can hear the second pair of horns clearly. This same set-up can work with a 6-member ensemble.
4 3 2 1 4 3 2 1 4 3 4 3 If working with 8 or more horns, I recommend a dual line format as opposed to one single line stretched across the stage. This avoids the problem of having a mixture of timbres because of a lack of uniformity in bell projection. Seating assignments may be derived from looking at the score and having like or similar parts seated one behind the other for security, intonation, and balance. If in an antiphonal format, it may be beneficial to have the choirs separated and seated in a mirror image so that the high horns are towards the center and the low horns located on the outside.
8 7 6 5 8 7 4 3 4 3 6 8 Performing ensemble music for horn is not only educational but is also fun. Horn ensemble music expands the range demands of the instrument, and illustrates to the student the powerfully expressive and heroic quality of the instrument. It also is an effective recruitment tool. I have included an annotated guide to horn ensemble literature for the public school horn section. This list is by no means inclusive, but will be a good reference to put your students. The majority of horn ensemble music is available from these publishers:
Baltimore Horn Club-7 Chapel Ct., Baltimore, MD 21093 In the list, middle c is c, third space treble c is c1, second space bass c is C. HORN QUARTETS
Grade 2
Pottag Quartet Album by Max Pottag
Three Short Pieces by A. O. Lively Grade 3
Canzona by Fiorenzo Maschera.
Cornocopia by Earl Hoffman.
Folk Song Suite arranged by Louis Stout and edited by Christopher Leuba Published by Southern Music.
Four Little Pieces by Rudolph Mayer.
Quartet for Horns by Max Pottag
Quartet Repertoire by various composers
Hunter's Delight by Reid Poole
Suite for Four Horns by Frances H. McKay
Solemn Music for Four Horns, by Hermann Jeurissen
Allegro, by Joseph Haydn; arranged by C. M. Jensen Grade 4
Divertimento No. 8, K. 213 by W. A. Mozart.
Four Canzoni transcribed by James Lee.
Quartet in B-Flat by Leopold Mêchura
Six Quartets by Franz Schubert arranged by Verne Reynolds Published by Southern Music.
Six Quartets by Robert Schumann arranged by Verne Reynolds Published by Southern Music.
Six Pieces by Nicolas Tcherepnine.
88 German Quartets, Edited by Thomas Bacon An outstanding collection of short to moderate length quartets consisting of folk tunes, marches, opera excerpts, and various chorale settings. These quartets are as grateful to the audience as they are to the performer. The Horn 4 book is written entirely in bass clef using old notation; written down an octave lower than performed. This may be daunting for the high school hornist, but those with youth orchestra experience should be able to rise to the challenge. This is an invaluable collection for the public school and collegiate horn section. However, the scoring is predictable as the first horn almost always gets the melody. Music for the Royal Fireworks, by G.F. Handel. Arranged by Leigh Martinet Published by Baltimore Horn Club. Range considerations: Horn 1 to a2; Horn 4 to G This is a lengthy, 5-movement transcription is difficult in terms of endurance. Because of this and the range required, it is advisable to use doubled parts. The 4th Horn part is almost exclusively written in bass clef. For hornists who are not familiar with this material, it would be advantageous for them to listen to a recording of the original. Use of a conductor will be required in the beginning stages of preparation. For an outstanding high school horn section, this work is well worth the effort. Grade 5
Concertino by Alexander Mitushin.
Cortettes by David Stanhope
Four Quartets arranged by Lowell Shaw
Fripperies (vol. 1) by Lowell Shaw
Hubertus-Serenade, by Bernhard Krol
Partita by Karl Etti Grade 6 Overture to The Magic Flute by W. A. Mozart. Trans. By H. Dutschke. Edited by Ralph Lockwood. Published by the Hornist's Nest. Range demands: Horn 1, up to g1; Horn 4, down to B. This exciting quartet requires four strong hornists of good stamina for a successful performance. It works best when two or more players are assigned to the parts. The dramatic opening chords that precede the exposition and development section need precision cueing and timing. Balance and clarity of line are problematic throughout, especially in fugal sections and multi-thematic imitative passages. Endurance is a definite factor for public school and some collegiate hornists. Attention to dynamic contrasts is essential for a successful performance. This is one of the landmark transcriptions for this medium.
Overture to The Marriage of Figaro by W. A. Mozart.
Suite for 4 Horns, by Albert Ingalls The majority of material for the body of this article came from conversations with Lowell Shaw, Leigh Martinet, and James Decker. Other material came from the Los Angeles Horn Club website and the Vienna Waldhorn Verein Newsletter. Dr. Eldon Mtlick |